As investment professionals, we need to dimension the financial impact on emerging markets equity returns, particularly given our overweight to equities, including those of emerging markets (EM).
For second quarter 2021, to date through May 4, EM equities (MSCI EM) have returned 1.51%. This compares to 4.79% for U.S. equities (Russell 1000 Index) and 2.63% for international developed equities (MSCI EAFE). While markets have held EM in slight disfavor during 2Q 2021, there has not been a particularly wide performance dispersion among these equity asset classes.
Index weights and return contributions of the 10 largest markets in the EM index are illustrated in Table 2. Indian equities have detracted 12 basis points (bps) from emerging market equities performance. While India has been the largest detractor among the top 10 markets, the negative contribution has not been particularly large. This is because India comprises only 9.3% of the EM index.
One issue for Indian equities is that firms are largely focused on the domestic market, rather than on export markets. So, the impact of the local COVID-19 situation is greater than might be seen in Taiwan or Korea.
India’s 12bps drag on EM equities returns was offset by China’s 24bps positive contribution. Given that China comprises 37% of the EM index, its contribution could have been greater were it not for the negative effects of the authorities’ efforts to impose antitrust regulation on the country’s mega-cap internet platforms: Alibaba, Tencent, and JD.com, among others. We detailed this situation in a recent Wilmington Wire. As 2021 progresses, we believe the existing platforms, and newer competitors, will emerge stronger than before.
We are encouraged by equity analysts’ expectations of sustainable high rates of earnings growth for these firms, as well as the relatively small size of the antitrust fines imposed on the platforms, which the firms have been able to easily pay out of their cash piles.
Table 2: Emerging markets weights and contributions for second quarter through May 5, 2021